Skip to main content

Mutsu vs. Shizuka smackdown

Two green apples

These Japanese apples have the same parents. How far does the family resemblance go?

On the left is Mutsu, big and green, and a little ribbed and blocky.

Mutsu (also known as Crispin) runs bigger than this, on average. I picked a "small" sample (still quite large!) knowing I'd be eating it with Shizuka.

Shizuka at right is smaller (though still large), tapered, and a paler, yellower green. It sports patches of a brown russet, and is not ribbed.

Shizuka has a faint orange-red blush, and a region of peel that was nearly yellow:

Spring green apple with small faint pink blush

Both are a little bit oblate, but Mutsu is huskier.

Taste and texture

Mutsu has coarse-grained juicy flesh that is just slightly yellow. Its crunch is decent, though not spectacular, with a little give. It bears delicate and attenuated flavors that might be muted floral, muted spice, and muted vanilla.

Despite all this tentativeness, Mutsu has a delicately astringent finish that is very grateful to the throat.

Shizuka is similar but with a crisper crunch. Its flesh is slightly less-coarse and a shade more yellow.

Spring green apple with small faint pink blush

Compared to Mutsu it is a bit fruiter, with faint corn syrup and cream soda and less flowers and spice.

Shifting back and forth highlights greater acidity in Mutsu, and faint pear notes and even a little nuttiness in Shikuza. All within a very narrow range.

The way that Mutsu brings these subtle qualities out in Shikuza suggests that this variety would be better and more interesting if it had just a little more tart acidity of its own.

So if you have a Shikuza, it might be worth pairing it with a more-tart variety to explore that side of it.

Mutsu does not fare so well following Shikuza in the mouth, but that might just be a casualty of the pairing that would not be obvious on its own.

Other considerations

Also, later in the season, or perhaps after storage, Mutsu can mellow and yellow, with a pretty orange blush.

I reviewed a late-season Mutsu in 2014.

Yellow apple with orange-pink blush

That midwinter Mutsu was "nearly a different apple," I found.

For this reason, I decline to pronounce either variety the winner of this little contest. But between the two samples I have today, when eaten together, I prefer the Shikuza.

Finally, some of my readers report that they are, sadly, allergic to apples, but can enjoy Mutsu without ill effects. If true, that alone would make Mutsu a significant apple.

Shikuza, like Mutsu, is a Golden Delicious x Indio cross, and very like its sibling. 

I would be interested to know if Shikuza also shares this hypoallergenic quality with Mutsu.

Note: I hope it is clear by my use of words like "if" in the above paragraphs that I am making no medical or dietary claims about these apples!

More


Comments

  1. I grew mutsu at my other house now i m growing shizuka which i prefer. I grow the two " stable-mates : KEEPSAKE & SWT -16 ( both from same parents) i prefer keepsake which gave HONEYCRISP ITS PUNCHY CRISPNESS BUT KEEPSAKE HANDS DOWN AN UGLY BUT SUPERIOR APPLE!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Join the conversation! We'd love to know what you think.