The encyclopedic website Pomiferous, cleverly organized and with links to related resources, is a labor of love by two "great friends," one an outdoors writer and the other a web designer.
This ambitious, generous site is a work in progress, rough edges, loose ends, and all.
Pomiferous is a massive database with some unique features of potential interest to growers and gardeners, including:
- apples by pollination group (cohorts of apples that bloom at the same time)
- search by no less than 12 uses ("pie" is its own category)
- a "Harvest Period Calculator" that, with some study, tells when an apple is likely to be ripe
The organization of individual entries varies but may include such information as how well an apple keeps in cold storage, its brix (sugar content), hardiness zone, and acidity.
Some listings provide links to further descriptive information in the U.S. National Germplasm System.
Since these data are not available for every variety, it takes a bit of poking around to see what might be included.
Mind the Gaps
In the loose-ends department are many question marks in the listings, possibly markers for further research by the authors. There is an apple called, as of this writing, literally "Katherine is the the same as." (Possibly Katharine, if I may be so bold.)
A project of this scope lends itself perhaps too easily to such observations. This is a splendid undertaking that belongs in the bookmarks of any apple aficionado. (I am adding it to mine.)
I am grateful that the authors have published the very great mass of information that is at their disposal today, rather than waiting until the perfect ideal is no longer the enemy of the good.
Just be aware that this is (and may always be) a work in progress. The home page features recent additions and changes.
Oceans of Apples
These are deft, if brief, and include such descriptive phrases as "buttery and perfumed," "brisk berry flavor," and "sweet with some sharpness, very nutty."
Many descriptions are perfunctory, but there are lots of them.
With all of that said, is it greedy of me to want to know the sources of these descriptions and this scholarship? It seems scarcely possible that the two great friends could have sampled all 8,000 varieties personally. (If they did, they should boast of it!)
The authors repeat without comment the story of how Wickson is a Newtown x Spitzenberg cross. Does Pomiferous expressly reject the alternative story, which is supported by the breeder's 1947 plant patent for Wickson? If so, on what basis?
In the face of the two friends' bountiful open-handedness, I feel a little mean raising questions like these. Pomiferous.com is a splendid project that will be a boon to apple lovers generally and growers particularly.
Its spirit reflects a generosity that I have come to recognize in the world of apples and cider.
Whence comes the claim that Mountain Rose is a sport of Airlie Redflesh? I can well believe it, but who says so? How do we know?
I have been doing some coorespondence with these 2 over the past 6 months. Providing input, some corections- that they are very supportive about. So it is a work in progress and suggests a larger audience of (apple) afficianados. It is an extremely helpful site as I navigate my own GROWING collection, as I trail apples on nearly 2 dozen rootstock combinations, now totaling 340.
ReplyDeleteThat was my take too! I certainly hope this does not come off as negative.
DeleteHi, this is Paul, one of the "great friends" at pomiferous. George is the apple guy, I'm the techy one. Thanks for you very fair review of Pomiferous.com. It's definitely a work in progress, both as a technical challenge for me and the Apple data on George's side. We are definitely open to comments/updates about the data on each apple. George knows a lot but he freely admits he doesn't know everything. We do like to get more information on the varieties and if they are supported with sources/references that's even better. We strive to be accurate even if it's ultimately a goal that can never be fully achieved.
ReplyDeleteThe sections of ????? in the text are still scattered in there, particularly in the less popularly accessed varieties. We do try to clean up as we go along.
I enjoyed your review and have sent the link to George.
Kind Regards
Paul H
Paul, congratulations and thank you to you and George!
DeleteThis is a great achievement, and I am very pleased to hear from you.