A recent visit to the Big Apple included a pilgrimage to several farmers markets. New York City draws fruit from some fine orchards upstate and in New Jersey.
I returned with 4 varieties I hoped to add to my opinionated catalog. All but one, however, were retreads in disguise.
I don't regret this. You can learn a lot by revisiting an apple variety that may have been picked at a different time under different conditions. I do so deliberately from time to time.
My 4 New York apples are as follows.
Golden Supreme (as "Early Golden")
A few sources note that Early Golden is an alternative name for this variety, and except for size (which varies) they are dead ringers.
I cannot kick about being fooled because (1) Golden S is a really nice apple and (2) mine was a gift from a generous cider maker.
Spartan ("Spartan Mac")
This one did not really surprise me, but I bought it just in case.
It's a Spartan, though.
Paula Red ("Summer Mac")
This late-season Paula really had me fooled. It was so different from the ones in August that I really had to convince myself it was not a separate variety.
The texture was softer and there are some really nice flavors (vanilla and even coconut) I'd never found in Paula before.
But I couldn't ignore all the sources linking Summer Mac to Paula as an alternative name. Instead I learned a little more about this apple.
Niagara ("Niagara Mac")
It's been like this all summer, actually, apples I've already met masquerading as something new or at least different. Often it's just not clear if I am getting a whole new variety or just a sport (minor variant) of one I know already.
Many growers don't seem to know, at least the ones working the crowds at farmers market. To be fair, most people don't care, if the apple is good.
Part of it is surely marketing, as with the premium Kiku apples that flood the supermarkets in the off season (they are Fujis, why not say so?). Part of it may be confusion or just an older name resurfacing.
When I taste something for the first time, I deliberately postpone research (which always starts online) until after I've recorded my own impressions. In this way I avoid being influenced by others.
I may have to rethink that practice!