Skip to main content

Quadropomia

SPOT THE RINGER

Four apples of different color and shape

I am delighted to have these four different apples from the Midwest Apple Improvement Association. Specifically, from David Doud in Indiana. ¶ 

Three of these are modern MAIA apples. One of those has been trademarked, so presumably has progressed from development to production. But the fourth was created by a much older fruit-breeding program in 1899.

Can you spot it? Bonus points for picking out the MAIA apple that is patented, trademarked, and in production.

If you have a large screen, click on the photo for a closer look.

David is a MAIA founder and board member. He grows apples on his Countyline Farm, about 60 miles north of Indianapolis.

As for the apples, stay tuned!

Comments

  1. Left one may be a definitely ripe Amarilla Soul . Others appear to be highly russetted for a modern apple.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The idea that any of these four could be a modern apple released into production in the age of glossy perfect-looking Delicious and Honeycrisp is mind-blowing.

      Delete
  2. No way could I spot the trademarked one, as they all look like heirloom apples. The one on the left resembles a heavily russeted Cox's Orange Pippin. That said, the idea of breeding and patenting a throwback-looking apple is extremely cool!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I would guess that the third one is Sweet Zinger. I can't find very many pictures of that one, but it's parent goldrush has a tendency to russet, so I could believe it. I'm confused by their marketing of apples as "open-pollinated honey crisp". Presumably that means an unplanned cross with honeycrisp?

    But I'm stumped by the ringer, unless the same one I've guessed already is actually opalescent, and the other anonymous commenter is right and the fourth apple is Amarilla Soul. That would be confusing, as they specifically market that apple as free of russet. Last guess would be that apple one is Cortland. I'll be interested to hear the real answers.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello - David Doud here. As a note, tho all of these varieties are normally rough appearing with varying amounts of russet, all are exhibiting more russet than average this year due to adverse weather, particularly the April 20th freeze event. The couple in the picture which might appear to be fully russeted in most years would present only a modest percentage of russet.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks Dave as well. This is a fun conversation. I am a hobby grafter and ended up with 300 trees planted and another 150 in my own small nursery without a real plan of what to do with them because of the fun of grafting. I did purchase a few MAIA trees though including Sweet Zinger ,Ever crisp, Rosalee,Ludacrisp. By luck over skill I avoided any significant russeting . I did cut back on Captan and sprayed more pencobez. and didn't fertilize much. My Spitzenbergs were the best ever. My opalescent (mentioned above) were very nice too.Very delicious too. Evercrisp seem juicer this year.
    Brian M... Northern Michigan
    I also commented earlier about the letter most apple.I need to sign up!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Join the conversation! We'd love to know what you think.